Resources: Checklist

SEO Audit Checklist

This is the SEO audit checklist I work through on client sites, in the order I work through it. Indexation problems first, then structure, on-page, content, speed, structured data, local and links. Every item is something you can check yourself with Search Console, a free crawler and your own eyes.

  • The same list I use on client work
  • No email required
  • Updated 2026-09-03

How to use this checklist

Work top to bottom and do not skip ahead. There is no point rewriting title tags on pages Google cannot index, and no point buying links for a site that takes eight seconds to load on mobile. Mark each item pass, fail or not applicable. When you reach the end, the fails are your work order, and the sections tell you which service the work belongs to.

You need three things to start: Google Search Console verified on the property, GA4 or any analytics with at least three months of history, and a crawler. Screaming Frog’s free tier covers 500 URLs, which is enough for most small business sites. Everything else on this list is free.

1. Access and baseline

  1. Search Console is verified for the exact property you rank with (domain property preferred, so http, https, www and non-www all report together).
  2. Export the Search Console Pages report (indexed and not indexed) and the last 12 months of Performance data before you change anything.
  3. Export the current top organic landing pages from analytics so you can prove what a change did later.
  4. Note the date of the last redesign, migration, hosting change or CMS update. Most sudden traffic drops trace back to one of these.
  5. List the pages that actually make money: the services, products or locations you want enquiries from. The audit is judged against these, not against a site-wide score.

2. Crawling and indexation

  • Your important pages return HTTP 200 and appear in the Search Console Pages report as indexed.
  • robots.txt does not block CSS, JavaScript, image folders or any section you want ranked. Read it line by line; a staging rule left in production is the single most expensive one-line mistake in SEO.
  • No page you want ranked carries a noindex meta robots tag or X-Robots-Tag header.
  • An XML sitemap exists, is linked in robots.txt, is submitted in Search Console, and contains only canonical, indexable, 200-status URLs.
  • The sitemap does not contain tag archives, author archives, paginated series, redirected URLs or noindexed pages.
  • Only one version of the site resolves: http redirects to https, and www and non-www settle on one host with a 301.
  • Every page has a self-referencing canonical, except deliberate duplicates that point to the original. Check one page of every template, not just the homepage.
  • “Crawled, currently not indexed” and “Discovered, currently not indexed” counts are low relative to the site. Large numbers usually mean thin, duplicated or orphaned pages.
  • No redirect chains or loops. Old redirects from previous migrations point straight to the final URL.
  • Internal links do not point to redirected or 404 URLs.
  • Parameter, filter, sort and search-results URLs are not crawlable in bulk, and are not eating crawl budget on a listing or store site.
  • If the site is built on React, Next.js, Vue or a page builder that renders client-side, view the raw HTML source (not the inspector) and confirm the main content, title, canonical and internal links exist without JavaScript.
  • No orphan pages: every page you want ranked is linked from at least one other page.

Anything failing here belongs to technical SEO, and if the failures started after a redesign, read website migration SEO before touching anything else.

3. Site structure and internal linking

  • Every service, product category and location you sell has its own page. A single “Services” page listing ten offerings cannot rank for any of them.
  • No two pages target the same search intent. Where they do, decide which one survives and redirect the other.
  • Commercial pages are reachable within three clicks of the homepage.
  • The main navigation reflects how customers think, not how the company is organised internally.
  • Breadcrumbs are present on deep pages and match the URL structure.
  • In-copy internal links use descriptive anchor text. Search the site source for “click here” and “read more” and replace them.
  • Hub pages link to every child page in body copy, and every child page links back up.
  • URLs are short, lowercase, hyphenated and stable. No dates, no numeric IDs, no stop-word soup.
  • Pagination, if used, is crawlable through real links rather than JavaScript-only “load more” buttons.

4. On-page elements

  • Every indexable page has a unique title tag, roughly 50 to 60 characters, with the main term near the front.
  • Every indexable page has a unique meta description that says what the page offers and for whom. Duplicated or missing descriptions are a fast win.
  • Exactly one H1 per page, containing the main term naturally.
  • H2 and H3 headings describe the sections and match the sub-questions people actually ask. Headings are not used purely for styling.
  • The first paragraph answers the query rather than introducing the company.
  • The main term appears naturally in the copy and is not repeated to hit a density target.
  • Images have descriptive file names, alt text that describes the image, and are not 3 MB screenshots.
  • Every page has one obvious next action: call, WhatsApp, form or booking.
  • Titles and descriptions are not truncated in the search results. The title and meta description checker shows lengths quickly.

Failures here are on-page SEO work.

5. Content quality

  • Each important page answers the question a searcher typed, in its own words, with specifics: price ranges, timelines, who it suits, what happens next.
  • No page is thin: under about 200 words of real content on a commercial page usually means it cannot compete.
  • No duplicated blocks across service or location pages with only the city or product name swapped.
  • Nothing is copied from a manufacturer, supplier or reference site.
  • Facts, prices, phone numbers, staff and opening hours are current.
  • Pages that make claims about health, money or safety name a qualified author or reviewer and carry a date.
  • AI-drafted content has been checked, corrected and given something only you know: your process, your prices, your photographs, your cases.
  • The blog answers pre-purchase questions and links to the service that answers them, rather than publishing news nobody searches for.
  • Old posts that still rank have been updated rather than replaced.

The gaps you find here are the input for content SEO and strategy, and the content brief template is how I plan each replacement page.

6. Speed and Core Web Vitals

  • The Search Console Core Web Vitals report shows mostly “good” URLs on mobile. Field data beats any lab score.
  • Largest Contentful Paint is under 2.5 seconds on mobile for your money pages.
  • Cumulative Layout Shift is under 0.1: nothing jumps as fonts, ads or chat widgets load.
  • Interaction to Next Paint is under 200 ms.
  • Server response time is under about 600 ms. On cheap shared hosting it often is not, and every other fix is a rounding error until that is addressed.
  • Images are sized for their container, compressed, served in a modern format and lazy-loaded below the fold.
  • Third-party scripts are counted and justified: chat widgets, review badges, heat maps, several analytics tools and a tag manager with forgotten tags are usually most of the mobile load.
  • Render-blocking CSS and JavaScript are minimised, and fonts are preloaded with a fallback so text is visible while they load.
  • Caching and a CDN are in place, which matters more when the audience is outside the country the server sits in.

This is the work covered by website speed and Core Web Vitals optimization.

7. Mobile and usability

  • The mobile page contains the same important content as the desktop page. Nothing critical is hidden or removed at small widths.
  • Tap targets are large enough and not stacked on top of each other.
  • Text is readable without zooming.
  • Phone numbers are click-to-call, and any WhatsApp link opens the app with a prefilled message.
  • Forms work on a phone, with the right keyboard type per field and as few fields as you can defend.
  • No intrusive interstitial covers the content as the page loads.

8. Structured data

  • Organization or LocalBusiness markup exists once, site-wide, with the real name, address, phone, logo and social profiles.
  • Service, Product, Article, FAQ, Event or Course markup is applied where the page type justifies it.
  • BreadcrumbList markup matches the visible breadcrumb.
  • Markup describes what is actually on the page. Marking up FAQs that no visitor can see is a policy problem, not a shortcut.
  • Everything validates in the Rich Results Test and the Schema Markup Validator, and Search Console reports no structured data errors.

Larger implementations are the schema markup service.

9. Local SEO, if you have a location

  • The Google Business Profile is claimed, verified and owned by the business rather than a former agency.
  • The primary category is the most specific accurate one, and secondary categories cover the rest.
  • Name, address and phone match the website, the signboard and every directory listing.
  • Hours, including festival and holiday hours, are current.
  • Recent photographs taken by you, not stock images.
  • Reviews arrive steadily and every one is answered, including the negative ones.
  • There is only one profile per physical location. Duplicates split reviews and confuse the map pack.
  • The website has a location page per branch with an embedded map, directions and local content.

The full version of this section is the local SEO checklist, and the service is local SEO.

  • You know which sites link to you and whether they are real: check the Search Console Links report first, since it is free and accurate about what Google sees.
  • No paid link packages, blog networks, comment spam or directory blasts in the profile. If there are, they are the first thing to deal with.
  • Anchor text from external links looks natural rather than stuffed with commercial terms.
  • Obvious honest opportunities are taken: suppliers, partners, associations, sponsorships, news coverage, alumni and event listings.
  • Brand mentions without a link have been asked to link.
  • Competitors’ link sources have been reviewed for the ones you could genuinely earn.

If a manual action or a traffic collapse followed link building, start at penalty and traffic drop recovery; otherwise this is link building.

11. Measurement

  • GA4 is installed once, not twice, and is not counting your own visits.
  • Calls, WhatsApp clicks, form submissions and bookings are tracked as events and marked as key events.
  • Search Console is linked to GA4 so you can see queries alongside behaviour.
  • You can answer one question in under a minute: how many enquiries did organic search produce last month, and from which pages?
  • Rank tracking, if you use it, is a diagnostic, not the report you judge the work by.

The setup detail is in the GA4 and GTM setup checklist.

What to do with the results

Sort the failures by how much traffic or revenue they touch, not by how easy they are. In practice the order is nearly always: fix indexation, then speed on the money pages, then split the pages that target more than one intent, then rewrite the thin commercial pages, then local, then links. Give each fix an owner and a date, and re-run this list after eight weeks.

If you would rather have this done for you, send me the URL through the free SEO audit form and I will run the crawl and the Search Console review and reply with the findings that matter. The paid version, with fix specifications and implementation, is the complete SEO audit service. The rest of my checklists and guides are on the resources page.

Last updated 2026-09-03.

Updated

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take to work through this checklist?

For a small business site of 20 to 50 pages, half a day for the checks and a day or two to write up what you found. Most of the time goes into the crawl and into reading Search Console properly rather than glancing at the summary. On a store or portal with thousands of URLs it is a week, because you check one page of every template rather than every page.

What tools do I need, and do they cost anything?

Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, the Rich Results Test and GA4 are free and cover most of the list. Screaming Frog crawls 500 URLs free, which is enough for a small site. Paid tools such as Ahrefs or Semrush make the link and competitor sections faster but nothing here strictly requires them.

Which failures should I fix first?

Anything that stops a page being indexed, because nothing else matters until it is fixed. Then server and mobile speed on the pages that earn money. Then pages that target more than one intent or no intent at all. Ease of fixing is a tie-breaker, not the ranking criterion.

Ready to talk about your project?

A free 30-minute call, a straight answer about what would move the numbers, and a written proposal within 48 hours if we are a fit.