What a subheadline does
A headline has to be short enough to be read at a glance, which means it always leaves something out. The subheadline is where that something goes: who the offer is for, what it actually involves, what makes it different, or what happens when the reader clicks. Together the two lines should answer the reader’s first question — is this for me, and is it worth another moment?
The division of labour is fairly consistent. The headline carries the promise or the result. The subheadline carries the proof, the qualification or the mechanism. “Google Ads that pay for themselves” is a promise; “managed weekly for Nepali service businesses, with the cost per enquiry reported every month” is what makes it believable.
It also sets the reading speed. A visitor who has read two lines and understood them is far likelier to carry on down the page than one who has read a slogan and is still guessing.
Why the subheadline matters
Most of a page’s readers never get past the top. Whatever share of them continue is decided in that opening pair of lines, which means the subheadline is doing more work than any paragraph further down. On a phone it matters more still, because there is less on screen and the reader is quicker to leave.
It is also the safety net for a headline that had to be short or clever. A punchy headline that could apply to several industries becomes specific the moment the line beneath names the industry, the region or the constraint.
Where subheadlines go wrong
The most frequent waste is restatement. If the headline says “grow your business online” and the subheadline says “we help businesses grow online”, the reader has been given nothing and the page has spent its most valuable space.
The second is abstraction. Lines built from words like innovative, holistic, seamless and end-to-end survive review meetings precisely because they commit to nothing, and they leave the reader no better informed.
The third is length. A subheadline that runs to several lines on a phone stops being a supporting line and becomes a paragraph the reader will skip. If it needs that much room, the content belongs further down the page.
Getting it right
Write the headline and subheadline as a pair, never separately, and test them by covering everything else on the page. If someone unfamiliar with the business can say what is on offer and who it is for from those two lines alone, they are doing their job.
Prefer the concrete to the impressive. Name the audience, the place, the timeframe, the format, or the thing the reader will be able to do — whichever is the strongest true detail you have. Match the wording to whatever brought the visitor here, since a mismatch between an ad and the top of the page is one of the quiet causes of poor landing page performance. Then read both lines aloud on a phone screen; anything you stumble over is a line the reader will stumble over too.
