How a free shipping threshold works
You set an order value at which delivery becomes free, and you tell the shopper how far away from it they are. Anyone below the line then has a choice: pay for delivery, or add something and pay nothing for it. Most people would rather spend the difference on a product than on postage, which is the whole reason the tactic works.
The line itself is a margin decision, not a marketing one. Set it too close to a typical basket and you give delivery away on orders that would have happened anyway. Set it far above and shoppers simply ignore it. The workable position sits a little above the value most of your orders already reach — close enough that one more item gets there.
Why a free shipping threshold matters
Delivery cost is one of the most common reasons a basket is abandoned, especially when it appears late in checkout. A threshold turns that cost into something the shopper can control, which removes the unpleasant surprise even for people who never reach the line. It is one of the few checkout changes that also improves the cart abandonment rate.
It is also one of the few levers that raises average order value without touching prices or buying traffic. The extra item carries its own margin, and if that margin covers the delivery you have given away, the shop is no worse off and the customer has more of what they wanted.
Where free shipping thresholds go wrong
Funding it from low-margin products is the expensive mistake. If the item a shopper adds to cross the line earns less than the delivery costs, every crossed threshold loses money. Work the sum on gross profit per order rather than on order value.
Announcing it too late is the other. A threshold that appears only in the basket cannot influence what a shopper puts in it. And a single national line can be quietly unprofitable when delivery outside the main cities costs considerably more, so either set the line by delivery zone or accept that cost knowingly.
How to act on it
Look at the distribution of your order values rather than the average, find the point where a meaningful group of baskets sits just below, and set the line above it. Then show progress towards it on the product page, in the basket drawer and at checkout, with plain wording that says how much more is needed rather than a general claim about free delivery.
Watch the effects together: basket value, order count, margin per order and the return rate, since items added only to reach a line come back more often than items someone genuinely wanted. Treat any change to the threshold as a test with a clear before and after, exactly as you would any other conversion rate optimisation change, and revisit it whenever courier pricing moves.
