Analytics and Tracking

Manual Actions Report

Also called Manual action report, Google penalty notice

Where Search Console tells you a human reviewer at Google has penalised your site, on what grounds and over which pages.

Quick facts: Manual Actions Report

Category
Analytics and Tracking
Also called
Manual action report, Google penalty notice
Level
Advanced
Affects
Rankings, indexing, recovery planning
Where to see it
Google Search Console (Security and Manual Actions)
In this article4
  1. How the manual actions report works
  2. Why the manual actions report matters
  3. Where manual actions go wrong
  4. How to act on it

How the manual actions report works

Most of what happens to your rankings is decided by systems running without human involvement. Occasionally a reviewer at Google looks at a site directly, decides it breaks the spam policies, and applies a penalty by hand. That decision is published in this report, under security and manual actions, and it is the only place you are told about it.

Each entry names the objection — unnatural links pointing at the site, unnatural links pointing out from it, thin content with little added value, user-generated spam, cloaking, deceptive redirects, or spam-heavy structured markup among others — and states the scope. A site-wide action affects everything. A partial action affects named URLs or sections, and the report lists examples so you can see what triggered it.

The consequence is demotion or removal from results, and it does not lift by itself. You fix the cause, then submit a reconsideration request explaining what you changed, and a person reviews the site again.

Why the manual actions report matters

It converts a mystery into a specific instruction. When search traffic collapses, the possible causes range from a technical fault to a competitor improving to an update in Google’s ranking systems, and untangling them takes time. This report either names the problem outright or removes the worst possibility from the list in seconds.

It matters most when you inherit a site. Buying a domain, taking over an agency’s account or restarting a neglected site are all situations where a penalty from someone else’s shortcuts is waiting for you, and this is where it shows.

Where manual actions go wrong

The frequent misunderstanding is assuming that a drop implies an action. Manual actions are uncommon; for almost every site the report is empty and should be. An empty report during a traffic decline is information, not disappointment: it points you towards algorithmic, technical or competitive causes instead.

The second is requesting reconsideration too soon. A request that arrives while the offending links are still live, or with a vague promise to do better, is refused, and each refusal costs you time. Reviewers are looking for evidence that the cause is gone, not an apology.

The third is treating a partial action as minor. It is a written statement that Google’s own reviewers consider part of your site spam, and it usually indicates a pattern rather than an isolated page.

How to act on it

Read the stated reason literally and fix that. For link problems, that means removing or disavowing what you can and stopping whatever produced them. For thin content, it means removing or genuinely rewriting the pages rather than adding words to them.

Then write the request as a factual account: what caused the problem, what you removed, what you changed, and what stops it happening again. Include specifics rather than adjectives. Google publishes no timetable for review, so build no campaign around a recovery date. If the site’s problems predate you, penalty recovery work normally starts with a full inventory of links and pages before anything is submitted.

Do and do not

Do

  • Check it first when search traffic collapses
  • Remove the cause completely before requesting review
  • Describe exactly what you changed in the request

Do not

  • Assume every ranking drop is a penalty
  • Submit a request while the problem is live
  • Try to outweigh bad links with new ones

Questions people ask about this

My traffic dropped but the manual actions report is empty. What does that mean?

It means no human reviewer has penalised your site, which is the usual state for almost every site. The decline has another cause: a change in Google's ranking systems, a technical fault such as pages falling out of the index, seasonality, or competitors improving. Ruling out a manual action early is useful, because it narrows the investigation considerably.

How long does it take for a manual action to be lifted?

Google does not publish a timetable, and a reconsideration request is reviewed by a person rather than processed automatically. What you control is the quality of the fix. A request submitted before the cause is genuinely removed will be refused, and each refusal adds another round trip, so it is faster overall to fix thoroughly and submit once.

Can I recover from an unnatural links action by building better links?

No. Adding new links does not cancel the ones the reviewer objected to. The work is removal and disavowal of the links that broke the policies, plus stopping whatever created them, whether that was a paid scheme, a directory run or an old agency's tactics. Better links help the site afterwards, but they are not the remedy.

Related terms

Found this useful?

Share it, or ask an AI to summarise it

Back to the glossary

Knowing the term is the easy part

Applying it to your own site and budget is the work. Book a call and I will tell you what actually applies to you.