What counts as a link scheme
Google’s spam policies name behaviours rather than a threshold. Buying or selling links that pass ranking signals, excessive link exchanges, large-scale article campaigns with keyword-heavy anchors, automated link creation, requiring a link as a condition of a contract or terms of service, and bulk directory or bookmark submissions all sit in the same policy. The common element is intent: links created mainly to influence rankings rather than to help a reader.
Note what is not on the list. A link you never asked for, a link from a small site, a link carrying a nofollow attribute, or a link from a partner you genuinely work with are none of them schemes. Nor is advertising, provided the link is disclosed as sponsored.
Why link schemes matter
Two reasons. The first is that they can be detected, and the consequences land on the site that benefits: an algorithmic devaluation that quietly removes the gains, or a manual action that a human reviewer applies and a human reviewer has to lift. The second is that the money is usually wasted even when nothing is caught, because the links are discounted rather than punished and the invoice arrives regardless.
The risk is worst when the buyer did not know. Plenty of businesses inherit a scheme from a previous agency, discover it during a migration or an audit, and end up paying for the cleanup on top of the original fee.
Where link schemes go wrong
Footprints. Networks built to look independent rarely are: shared hosting, the same template, recycled author names, the same small set of outbound targets, the same interlinking shape. Anchor text gives them away too, because real editors write your brand name or an ordinary descriptive phrase, while a scheme writes the money keyword over and over.
The other failure is timing. Links appear in bursts tied to invoice dates rather than to anything happening in the world, then stop the month a contract ends. That shape looks nothing like the coverage a genuinely newsworthy business attracts.
What to do about it
If you are buying links now, stop and take an inventory before deciding anything else. Export every referring domain, mark what came from a paid, exchanged or network source, and look at what remains — many sites find the legitimate part of the profile was doing most of the work all along. Request removal where a contact exists, disavow what will not come down, and do not file a reconsideration request until the cleanup is genuinely finished.
If you are choosing a supplier, the question is not how many links they will build but where each one will sit and why that publisher would want it. A supplier who will not name sources is selling a scheme. Honest link building is slower, far cheaper to defend, and does not have to be undone later.
