Analytics and Tracking

Ahrefs and Semrush

Also called SEO tools, backlink tools

Third-party SEO platforms that estimate rankings, traffic and link strength from their own crawls rather than from Google's data.

Quick facts: Ahrefs and Semrush

Category
Analytics and Tracking
Also called
SEO tools, backlink tools
Level
Intermediate
Affects
Keyword planning, link strategy, technical audits
Where to see it
Ahrefs, Semrush, alongside Google Search Console for first-party data
In this article4
  1. How Ahrefs and Semrush work
  2. Why Ahrefs and Semrush matter
  3. Common mistakes with Ahrefs and Semrush
  4. What to do about it

How Ahrefs and Semrush work

Both companies run their own web crawlers and maintain a large index of pages, links and search results. From that index they build the numbers you see: which sites link to a page, which keywords a domain appears for, roughly what those rankings might be worth in traffic, and how hard a keyword looks to compete for. They also crawl your own site on request to produce a technical audit, and check your positions for a list of keywords on a schedule.

The important thing to understand is where those numbers come from. Google does not supply them. Estimated traffic is modelled by applying an estimated click curve to an estimated search volume. Keyword difficulty is a score the vendor invented. Site strength ratings such as Domain Rating or Authority Score are the vendor’s own scales, calculated from their own link index — not something Google publishes, and not something Google uses.

Why Ahrefs and Semrush matter

They are the only practical way to see outside your own site. Search Console tells you what your pages do; these platforms tell you what competitors rank for, which of their pages attract links, which topics you have no coverage of at all, and who has recently started outranking you. For planning a content programme or a link strategy, that outside view is what turns a plan into something better than a guess.

They are also good at the unglamorous work. Crawling a site to find broken links, redirect chains, missing titles, thin duplicates and pages that no internal link points to produces findings that are factual rather than modelled, and that part of the output is where I trust them most.

Common mistakes with Ahrefs and Semrush

Treating a vendor score as Google’s opinion is the big one. Domain Rating and Authority Score are useful for comparing two candidates on the same scale — is this site stronger than that one — and close to useless as a target. A proposal that promises to raise a vendor score is selling a number rather than a result. Judge SEO on rankings for terms that matter, on organic traffic, and on enquiries that arrive.

The second is reading a traffic estimate as a forecast. Estimates are models, and models are least accurate exactly where they are most interesting: small markets, local languages and low-volume commercial terms. For Nepal in particular, the underlying volume and click data are thinner than for large English-speaking markets, so use the figures to rank opportunities against each other, never as a promise of what a page will earn.

What to do about it

Use the tools for direction and your own data for judgement. Take the keyword list, the competitor gap and the technical crawl from the platform. Take impressions, clicks and average positions from Search Console. Take conversions from your analytics. When they disagree, first-party data wins, every time.

Subscribe deliberately as well. Both are expensive enough to matter to a small business, and much of the value comes in bursts: a month of research at the start of a project, a crawl before and after a migration, an occasional link review. What you cannot outsource to a subscription is the thinking — deciding which pages deserve the work is keyword research and competitor analysis, not an export.

Do and do not

Do

  • Check tool findings against Search Console before acting
  • Use vendor scores to compare, never as targets
  • Subscribe in bursts around research and migrations

Do not

  • Report estimated traffic as though it were measured
  • Promise or accept a promise to raise Domain Rating
  • Trust volume estimates for small markets and local languages

Questions people ask about this

Is Domain Rating or Authority Score a Google ranking factor?

No. Both are scores invented by the tool vendors and calculated from their own link indexes. Google neither publishes nor uses them. They are handy for comparing two sites on the same scale when you are assessing a link opportunity, but raising the score is not a goal, and any supplier who sells it as one is selling the wrong thing.

Why does the tool's traffic estimate not match my analytics?

Because the estimate is a model, not a measurement. It combines estimated search volume with an assumed click pattern, and it cannot see your branded traffic, your direct visits, your paid clicks or anything from channels it does not crawl. Use it to compare opportunities against each other, and use Search Console and analytics for what actually happened.

Do I need both Ahrefs and Semrush?

Rarely. Their link indexes and keyword databases differ, so a large agency may keep both for cross-checking, but for one business the overlap is heavy and the second subscription buys little. Pick whichever covers your market and language better, test it against terms you already rank for, and spend the difference on producing pages.

Related terms

Found this useful?

Share it, or ask an AI to summarise it

Back to the glossary

Knowing the term is the easy part

Applying it to your own site and budget is the work. Book a call and I will tell you what actually applies to you.